Joint press statements by NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg with Irakli Kobakhidze, Prime Minister of Georgia

Source: NATO

So, Prime Minister Kobakhidze, welcome to NATO, it’s great to see you here.

We have met before but this is the first time we meet in your new capacity as Prime Minister and therefore let me start by congratulating you on your appointment as Prime Minister and we look forward to working with you.

Georgia is a close NATO partner, and we fully support Georgia’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.

NATO continues to call on Russia to reverse the recognition of Georgian territories as independent states.
Any threats by Russia to annex Georgia’s occupied regions are unacceptable.

This week, we mark the second anniversary of Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.

Ukraine’s withdrawal from Avdiivka shows that the situation on the battlefield is extremely difficult.

But the Ukrainians have exceeded expectations over and again. And NATO continues to stand with Ukraine.

Just in the last few days, Allies have announced new military support packages worth billions of euros. Including for air defences, artillery ammunition, and F-16 equipment. 

NATO partners are also playing a key role, and I welcome that Georgia is providing humanitarian and financial aid, and hosting thousands of Ukrainian refugees.

At our meeting today, we will also address security in the Black Sea region which I know is of great importance for Georgia.

Russia’s war against Ukraine poses substantial risks to the freedom of navigation. This also impacts food security around the world. So I welcome the efforts of Allies working to demine the Black Sea, making it safer for navigation and commerce.

In our meeting today we will also discuss the partnership between NATO and Georgia, and how to develop it further.

I welcome the progress made in areas like crisis management, cyber security, military engineering, and secure communications.

I also congratulate you on gaining candidate status with the European Union.

Now it is important for Georgia to continue and step up domestic reforms and uphold democratic values.

We want to see Georgia move in the right direction. Toward more democracy and prosperity. Toward full membership in the Euro-Atlantic family.

NATO will continue to stand by your side as you work toward fulfilling those aspirations.

So Prime Minister, once again welcome, it’s great to see you here at the NATO headquarters.

Deputy Secretary General: NATO is strengthening its partnership with the space industry

Source: NATO

Speaking at NATO’s first Space Reverse Industry Day on Tuesday (20 February 2024), Deputy Secretary General Mircea Geoană highlighted the importance of cooperation with commercial space industry to ensure Alliance security. “This is not a job for NATO alone. It is something we must do together,” he said.

Faced with ever-fiercer world competition and fast-evolving technological innovation, Allies have to enhance their defences and resilience in the space domain. The Space Reverse Industry Day gave space companies the opportunity to share their unique perspectives and help shape NATO’s commercial space agenda. Discussions ranged from addressing commercial challenges with public sector organisations; exploring initiatives for new multinational space investments; considering space innovation activities through DIANA, to streamlining and enhancing space standardization and interoperability.

Space companies from 21 NATO nations took part in the event, from satellite manufacturer and satellite communications companies to space robotics companies developing in-orbit servicing technologies. A large majority included start-ups, small- and medium-enterprises and non-traditional defence companies. 

NATO’s first space policy was approved in 2019, and space officially became an operational domain that same year. Eighteen NATO Allies and Sweden will soon launch the “Alliance Persistent Surveillance from Space” initiative, which will help increase NATO’s data collection and use from commercial and national satellites and enhance NATO’s intelligence and surveillance picture.

Chair of the NATO Military Committee attends the 53rd NATO Defense College Academic Advisory Board meeting

Source: NATO

On 19th and 20th February 2024, the NATO Defense College Academic Advisory Board (AAB) convened its 53rd annual meeting in Rome, Italy. The AAB advises the Commandant on ways in which to improve the academic, research and outreach activities of the College, to enhance links with NATO HQ and Allied Command Transformation, and to ensure that the College’s outreach strategies align with those of the Alliance.

The meeting began with Opening Remarks from the Commandant of the NATO Defense College (NDC), Lieutenant General Max Nielsen and the Chair of the NATO Military Committee, Admiral Rob Bauer. As Chair of the AAB, Admiral Bauer laid out the agenda and objectives for the meeting, adding, that “these discussions provide the AAB and the NDC with an excellent opportunity to explore current and future requirements NATO may have in the domains of education, training as well as research and innovation”.

The Board received an update from the Director of the NDC’s Research Division, Dr. Florence Gaub who briefed on the 2024 Research Plan, the College’s most recent publications and new areas to be exploited. The Board also received an update on the NDC’s ongoing education programme as well as the scheduled exercises for 2024, and an update on NDC engagement activities.

In his closing remarks, Lieutenant General Nielsen highlighted his desire to find ways for the NDC to support NATO. “In order to do that, the guidance from the Academic Advisory Board, some of our most important stakeholders, is crucial to help us identify areas where we can improve and innovate our education, research, engagement, and enablement tasks for the betterment of our Alliance and our partners”, he concluded.

Admiral Bauer commended the NDC for the essential role it has been playing in the education of NATO’s future leaders and highlighted the excellent work the College has been doing with its outreach to Partners. “All in all, over 60 nations are able to attend these courses and benefit from this international environment, which enables Allied and Partner participants to engage with each other, learn from each other and encourage their personal growth”, he remarked.

Concluding the meeting, Admiral Bauer encouraged the NDC to continue “striving for excellence, and to maintain its status as the Alliance’s premier education and training institution, as well as its leading research and innovation facility”.

On the side-lines of the AAB meeting, Admiral Bauer gave a lecture to the members of the Senior Course, the NATO Regional Cooperation Course and the ongoing Modular Short Course on “NATO’s new Era of Collective Defence”. Participants included military and civilians representatives from 40 NATO and Partner Nations.

Other members of the Board in attendance: Ms Marie-Doha Besancenot (NATO International Staff); Vice Admiral Guy Robinson (ACT Representative); Major General Davide Re (ACO Representative); Major General Tiberiu Serban (NATO International Military Staff); Mr Mr Fergal Anthony O’Regan (European Security Defense College); Dr Bernard Finel (Marshall Center); Dr Pierre Razoux (FMES Institute), Professor Andrea Prencipe (Rector of LUISS); and Dr Jamie M. Johnson (Leicester University).

Secretary General meets NATO Parliamentary Assembly President, chairs annual meeting with parliamentarians

Source: NATO

NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg met with NATO Parliamentary Assembly (NPA) President Michal Szczerba at NATO Headquarters on Monday (19 February 2024) to discuss key issues on the European security agenda along with ways to maintain the strong cooperation between the two organisations.

Together with President Szczerba, the Secretary General chaired the annual meeting of the NPA with Permanent Representatives to the North Atlantic Council as part of the programme of regular engagements between NATO and the NPA. In meetings at committee level, Assembly members are set to discuss topics including defence spending, expanding the transatlantic industrial base, Ukraine’s path to NATO membership, regional security issues and energy security.

Mr Stoltenberg highlighted that the NPA provides an essential link between the Alliance and its democratic institutions, helping to foster awareness and understanding of NATO’s policies. The Secretary General underlined the importance of parliamentarians’ continued support in implementing the decisions taken at the NATO Summit in Vilnius last year, as well as in maintaining substantial aid to Ukraine. Looking ahead to the upcoming Summit in Washington D.C., Mr Stoltenberg stressed the crucial role of parliamentarians in informing and engaging NATO publics. 

The Secretary General also met with U.S. Representative Mike Turner, Chair of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence and Head of the U.S. Delegation to the NPA, to discuss the continued importance of NATO to the United States, and the urgent need to approve further aid to Ukraine.

The NPA is an inter-parliamentary organisation that brings together parliamentarians from NATO Allies and partner countries to discuss political, defence and security issues facing the Alliance.

Secretary General wraps up Munich Security Conference stressing importance of NATO unity, support to Ukraine

Source: NATO

Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg wrapped up three days of talks at the Munich Security Conference on Sunday (18 February 2024), underlining that the world has become more dangerous but that NATO has become stronger.

On Saturday, speaking alongside U.S. Senator Pete Ricketts and Estonian Prime Minister Kaja Kallas, Mr Stoltenberg said that the Alliance never takes peace for granted, but that there was no imminent military threat to any NATO Ally. Mr Stoltenberg pointed to record increases in Allied defence spending and arms production as examples of how the Alliance is adapting to a more dangerous world. On Ukraine, Mr Stoltenberg welcomed that European Allies and Canada are stepping up aid to Kyiv, and he warned that there was a “vital and urgent need” for the U.S. to follow suit. He further called on Russia to answer “serious questions” about the death of Alexei Navalny, underlining that Russia is ultimately responsible, and said that the best way to honour Navalny’s memory was to continue supporting the Ukrainians fighting for freedom and independence. 

In the margins of the conference, the Secretary General held a range of bilateral meetings, including with His Majesty King Abdullah II of Jordan; His Highness Prince Faisal bin Farhan Al-Saud, Foreign Minister of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia; Qatari Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs Mohammed bin Abdulrahman bin Jassim Al Thani; Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen of Denmark; Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre of Norway; Prime Minister Talat Xhaferi of North Macedonia; and President Jakov Milatović of Montenegro. 

In talks with two bipartisan U.S. Senate delegations, Mr Stoltenberg stressed that a strong NATO is in the U.S. national interest, and underlined the urgency of the United States approving further aid to Ukraine. He further pointed out that support to Ukraine is an example of true transatlantic burden-sharing, and welcomed historic increases in Allied defence spending.

While in Munich, the Secretary General also met with U.S. Special Presidential Envoy for Climate John Kerry; CEO of Google and Alphabet Sundar Pichai; President and CEO of Lockheed Martin James Taiclet; and a delegation from Boeing including President and CEO of Boeing Defense Ted Colbert, Senior VP of Global Public Policy Stephen Biegun, and Dr Brendan Nelson, President of Boeing Global. 

On Friday, the Secretary General attended the CSU Transatlantic Forum with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and the Minister-President of Bavaria, Markus Söder.

Secretary General in Munich: the world is more dangerous but NATO is stronger

Source: NATO

There is no imminent military threat to NATO but the Alliance never takes peace for granted, Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg said at the Munich Security Conference on Saturday (17 February 2024). “The world has become more dangerous, but NATO has become stronger,” said Mr Stoltenberg, citing record increases in Allied defence spending and ammunition production. On Ukraine, Mr Stoltenberg welcomed that European NATO Allies and Canada are stepping up aid to Kyiv, and warned that there is a “vital and urgent need for the US to decide on a package for Ukraine”.

Remarks by NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg at the Munich Security Conference panel discussion

Source: NATO

Christiane Amanpour
For you Secretary General, NATO has said, and actually key Defence Ministers from the frontline countries, have said that you are concerned for the first time. This wasn’t the case last year, that within three to five years even, Putin could test the resolve of a NATO country.

NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg
We can never take peace for granted, but I think it is important to convey that we don’t see any imminent threat against any NATO Ally. The world has become more dangerous, but NATO has become stronger. And the purpose of NATO is to prevent war, is to ensure that there is no room in Moscow for any miscalculation about NATO’s readiness and resolve to protect all Allies. And to make it clear that an attack on one Ally will trigger the response from the whole Alliance. And as long as we convey that message, clearly to Moscow, no Ally will be attacked. So our deterrence remains credible and therefore we don’t see any military threat against any NATO Ally.

Christiane Amanpour
Can I ask you to pick up on the progress that NATO nations are making in what you’re all demanding for more defence spending?

NATO Secretary General
In 2014, NATO made the very important decision, triggered by Russia’s illegal annexation of Crimea and also NATO Allies after years of reducing defence spending, we had to start to increase defence spending. And that was at the NATO Summit in Wales. I remember I was there. And I thought this was just another pledge by politicians and I made that international meeting and [thought] not so much was going to happen.

The reality is that a lot has happened because since then, all NATO Allies have increased defence spending. This year, we expect 18 Allies to meet the 2% guideline, spend 2% of GDP on defence. That’s up from three [Allies] in 2014. That’s a significant increase, meaning that in total European Allies and Canada have added 600 billion [dollars] extra for defence. And those Allies which are not yet at 2% have plans in place to be there very soon. So there is an enormous difference and the European Allies have really stepped up because they realise that there is need to invest in high-end capabilities, have more readiness of our forces. And NATO has implemented the biggest reinforcements on collective defence in generations with battlegroups, combat troops in the eastern part of the Alliance for the first time in our history, with high readiness, more forces, and now total new defence plans. So I’m not saying everything is fine. I agree that Europeans have to do even more, but they’re really on track to something which is demonstrating a commitment of all Allies that need to stand together.

Christiane Amanpour
Can you today be certain that NATO can defeat Russia, if it comes to that? All we’re hearing is that you’re not ramped up enough. You don’t have enough to do what you need to do in Ukraine, much less if you were to confront Russia, and you’ve said that if he steps on your territory, every single inch will be defended.

NATO Secretary General
NATO is the strongest military power in the world today. We represent 50% roughly of the world’s total military might. And militarily, we are stronger than Russia.

But at the same time, I think the war in Ukraine has demonstrated that there are some serious gaps. For instance, when it comes to sustainment, it’s one thing to have all the advanced weapons systems, but they need spare parts, they need maintenance, and obviously they need ammunition. And in the beginning of the war in Ukraine, we depleted our stocks, but now they are running quite low. So now we are focusing extremely, on how to ramp up production. We have some good news. There are new factories being set up. Production has increased but there’s an urgent need to do more.

So yes, I think we all have learned some serious lessons about warfare and also for NATO from the war in Ukraine. Then of course, I was speaking about burden sharing.  Europeans have more to do when it comes to total defence spending. But actually, when you look at support for Ukraine, European Allies and Canada have provided more support to Ukraine in total than United States. Of course, the United States have done a lot, in particular in constant military support to Ukraine. But the problem now is of course, the lack of decision in the US Congress means that the flow from the US has gone down. And that has a direct impact on the frontline in Ukraine. So of course, it’s not about making the right decision, but it’s about making the right decision early as quickly as possible because it’s urgent. Every week we wait means that there will be more people killed on the frontline in Ukraine. So it’s not for me to give advice on how to pass legislation through the US Congress. But what I can say is the vital and urgent need for the US to decide on a package for Ukraine because they need that support. And we have a burden sharing between Europe, Canada and the United States. Now it’s for the US to deliver what they promised.

Question
I’m [inaudible] Finland, Former Minister Sanna Marin’s government. It’s clear that Europe needs a credible and strong deterrence looking at Ukraine and beyond. Chancellor Scholz pointed out earlier this morning. Do you think that we can achieve that by conventional means only? Or is it timely to discuss the European nuclear weapon as it is being discussed currently in Germany? What are the expectations especially across the Atlantic?

NATO Secretary General
NATO has a well-established nuclear deterrent. It has worked for decades. It’s something the United States does together with European Allies. We have agreed command and control. We have exercises. We have doctrines and it’s actually something we do together as NATO. And I think that any questioning of that deterrent will only undermine NATO in a time when we really need credible deterrence. So of course we have US nuclear power. We have France and UK. But the idea of developing some kind of parallel joint nuclear deterrent among some NATO Allies, not including the United States and presumably not the UK either, that’s not helpful and it will only undermine a nuclear deterrent that’s worked well for many, many years.

Question
And thank you very much Tobias Ellwood, United Kingdom Parliament, former foreign minister. Senator [Ricketts] I understand this is the biggest delegation for the United States, for generations to come to Munich and that’s really good to see. I hope the message goes back that part of Europe is on fire. The lines on the map are being redrawn. And we are absolutely baffled as to how this has been tied in with what’s going on the Mexican border. My question, if I may, is to do a standardisation of NATO rounds. Because if you take a Howitzer from United States, and you put it with the munitions from Estonia, as Ukraine found, it won’t work. And we need to be building more artillery pieces and shells as well. But until we standardise this equipment, it simply won’t happen. Surely that must be a priority for NATO.

NATO Secretary General
Yes, absolutely. And the good news is that, again, we have learned some very serious lessons from the war in Ukraine. It’s not only Estonian Howitzers or ammunition from USA doesn’t work together. It’s also, we have a joint Dutch-German brigade where they discovered exactly the same. So we have too many examples where Allies have made some small changes in NATO standards partly, I guess, to protect their own industry. And this doesn’t work. So therefore, we have done a lot in NATO to actually reinforce and to implement the agreed NATO standards. This will reduce costs and it will ensure interoperability and also that weapons and ammunitions are interchangeable.

Christiane Amanpour
Question to both of you actually, because you’ve been using China more and more in your arguments to US lawmakers. And others have told us that they’re watching. You know, Iran is watching, China’s watching. Everybody’s watching what happens on the battlefield of Ukraine. And others have suggested that there is actually a new axis of anti-American nations, Iran, North Korea, you know, Russia joining to really challenge the United States. I’d like to hear your view on that. And then your answer on that.

NATO Secretary General
I think we have to remember that just a few days before the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine back in 2022, President Putin went to Beijing and he signed an agreement with President Xi where they promised each other a partnership without any limits. And what we see is that China and Russia are coming closer and closer. So of course, if President Putin wins in Ukraine, it’s not only challenging for the Ukrainians, but it sends a message not only to Putin, but also to Xi that when they use military force, they get what they want. So what happens in Ukraine today can happen in Taiwan tomorrow. And therefore, I strongly believe that it’s a good deal for the United States to support Ukraine. It’s not charity, it’s an investment in their own security. Because it makes it less likely that Xi uses force for instance, against Taiwan, but also because by spending a fraction of the US defence budget together with European Allies, we have enabled the Ukrainians to destroy a substantial part of the Russian fighting power. So this is actually in our interest to ensure that Putin doesn’t win. Not least because we are concerned about what China may learn if he wins in Ukraine. So therefore, it’s urgent that the US makes a decision on continuing support to Ukraine.

NATO Deputy Secretary General, Prime Minister of North Macedonia discuss discusses Western Balkan security, Ukraine support

Source: NATO

Deputy Secretary General Mircea Geoană met with Prime Minister Talat Xhaferi of North Macedonia for talks at NATO Headquarters on Tuesday (13 February 2024). They discussed security in the Western Balkans, support to Ukraine and preparations for the NATO Summit in Washington.

The Deputy Secretary General thanked the Prime Minister for North Macedonia’s commitment to the Alliance, including by contributing troops to NATO’s Kosovo peacekeeping mission and to the battlegroups in Romania, Bulgaria and Latvia. Mr Geoană welcomed North Macedonia’s commitment to increase its defence budget, building up to 2% of GDP this year. On Ukraine, Mr Geoană thanked Prime Minister Xhaferi for the military, financial and humanitarian support North Macedonia has provided to Ukraine, underlining that Allies’ continued support is making a difference on the battlefield.

On the Western Balkans, Mr Geoană emphasised that the region is of strategic importance for NATO as highlighted by the recent visit of the North Atlantic Council to Bosnia and Herzegovina. Amid secessionist threats, Mr Geoană said that the Alliance stood by Bosnia and Herzegovina’s territorial integrity. He recalled that the Alliance had increased its military presence in Kosovo following recent violence and would do what is necessary to keep the peace.

The two leaders further discussed preparations for the upcoming NATO Summit in Washington, including NATO’s push to invest more in defence and expanding the transatlantic industrial base. Marking the Alliance’s 75th anniversary, the Summit will send a strong message of unity and demonstrate that NATO is adapting to an uncertain and more dangerous security environment, the Deputy Secretary General said.
 

Doorstep statement by NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg ahead of the Munich Security Conference

Source: NATO

I am deeply saddened and concerned about reports coming from Russia that Alexei Navalny is dead. All the facts has to be established and Russia has serious questions to answer. 

Alexei Navalny has been a strong voice for freedom, for democracy for many years, and NATO and NATO Allies have called for his immediate release for a long time. 

And today my thoughts go to his family and his loved ones. And we remain committed to support everyone that believes in democracy and freedom as Alexei Navalny has done for so many years. 

Question: [inaudible] …regarding the causes of the death of Navalny?

NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg: We don’t have any information now. That’s the reason why it is important to have all facts established, and why Russia has some very serious questions to answer. What we have seen is that Russia has become a more and more authoritarian power, that they have used oppression against opposition for many years. And of course, he was in jail, he was a prisoner. And that makes it extremely important that Russia now answer all the questions that will be asked about the cause of the death.

Question: Mr Stoltenberg, we are only weeks away from the Russian presidential election. Could there be any connection to his passing now?

NATO Secretary General: I will not speculate today. I will just continue to call on Russia to make sure that all facts are established, that they answer all the questions that now will be asked. And then based on that we will be able to say more.

Question: [inaudible]… waiting for President Zelenskyy to attend the conference here. What kind of message can he take home especially when we consider that the US aid is stalled and that the Europeans are also struggling? Critics in Ukraine would say Europe failed us once when Crimea was annexed, is Europe gonna fail us again?

NATO Secretary General: Our task is to ensure that we continue to support Ukraine, because this is in our security interest to do so. And the situation is difficult. The fact that the United States has not made a decision has impacted the situation on the battlefield. At the same time, I continue to expect that the United States will make a decision to continue to provide support.

And it’s also important to actually recognise that even though the situation on the battlefield is difficult, we should not overestimate Russia and underestimate Ukraine. Just this week, the Ukrainians have demonstrated once again, their skill and their competence when it comes to deep strikes by sinking one of the Russian ships in the Black Sea. We have also seen new announcements of more support for Ukraine. At the NATO Defence Ministerial meeting this week, Allies announced more support for the F16s, more air defence. And several Allies also went together and promised to deliver 1 million drones to Ukraine.

And then of course, Ukraine is coming closer to NATO. We agreed to establish a new centre to help train and build capacity in Ukraine to learn lessons. And today also France and Germany are signing security assurances with Ukraine. I welcome these assurances; they’re not an alternative to NATO membership, but they help Ukraine to move closer to membership. So therefore, we need to continue to support Ukraine and ensure that Ukraine will become a member of the Alliance.

Question: On Navalny, what does it tell us about the nature of Putin’s regime, that the opposition leader has died in prison?

NATO Secretary General: Today my message is that we need to establish all the facts, and Russia needs to answer all the questions – and many serious questions – about the causes of his death. I’m deeply saddened and very concerned. And of course, Alexei Navalny was a very strong voice for freedom, for democracy. And therefore also NATO and NATO Allies called for his immediate release for a long time. And my main message today is to express my condolences and my thoughts are with his loved ones and his family. And then we need to come back to all the rest when we know more about the circumstances.

Question: What kind of support would you like to have from Latin American countries, Mr. Stoltenberg?

NATO Secretary General: I would like countries all over the world who believe in freedom and democracy to support Ukraine. Because it will not only be a tragedy for Ukraine if President Putin wins, but it will make the whole world more dangerous. Because then the message to authoritarian leaders all over the world will be that when they use military force, they get what they want. And then we all will become more vulnerable. And therefore it is extremely important that also countries in Latin America who believe in freedom, support Ukraine and stand up against the war of aggression against Ukraine. Thank you so much.

NATO Secretary General on reports of Alexei Navalny’s death

Source: NATO

NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg on Friday (16 February 2024) said he was “deeply saddened and disturbed” by reports about the death of jailed Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny. “All the facts has to be established and Russia has serious questions to answer”, Mr Stoltenberg said arriving at the Munich Security Conference. “We remain committed to support everyone that believes in democracy and freedom as Alexei Navalny has done for so many years.