Source: US FBI
Her Husband, Former U.S. Army Soldier Andrew Garasich, Was Previously Sentenced to 12 Years in Federal Prison
NASHVILLE – Lyndsey T. Bustamante, 29, of Clarksville, Tennessee, has been sentenced to 11 years and 4 months in federal prison for aggravated child neglect, announced Robert E. McGuire, Acting United States Attorney for the Middle District of Tennessee.
“The victim in this case was a two-month-old child who was horribly neglected by the Defendant and barely survived,” said Acting United States Attorney Robert E. McGuire. “The child is now in a loving home but will face lifelong struggles because of the Defendant’s choices. This case shows that we will not hesitate to prosecute those who hurt children and, if they are convicted, we will seek long sentences in federal prison for them.”
“This sentencing reaffirms our steadfast commitment to protecting our children, the most vulnerable among us,” said Special Agent in Charge Joe Carrico of the FBI Nashville Field Office. “Andrew Garasich and his wife, Lyndsey Bustamante, thought that they could act without consequences, but they were wrong. Let this serve as a warning: if you harm children in any way, the FBI and our law enforcement partners will find you and ensure you face the full consequences of your actions.”
“This sentencing marks another significant step towards justice for the victim in this horrific case,” said Special Agent in Charge John McCabe of the Department of the Army Criminal Investigation Division’s Midcentral Field Office. “Army CID remains dedicated to the safety and well-being of our communities.”
On December 30, 2022, Bustamante’s husband Andrew Garasich burned their two-month-old baby by giving him a bath in water that was too hot. Although Bustamante was away from home with her five-year-old son when Garasich burned the baby, Garasich notified her on December 30 about having burned their baby. Neither parent sought medical attention for the baby until January 4, 2023.
When interviewed by the FBI on May 3, 2023, Garasich told Agents he noticed the baby’s butt was “beet red” when he was drying him off after the bath. He reported he noticed some of the baby’s skin was peeling before he left the home with the baby to go to Edible Arrangements to pick up chocolate-covered strawberries for Bustamante. After he returned home with the baby, he began to remove skin from the baby’s body. Garasich told the Agents that when Bustamante came home on December 31, 2022, parts of the baby’s body were already peeling, and Garasich had already pulled some of the baby’s peeling skin off. After Garasich burned the baby in the bath, Bustamante bathed the baby again between December 31 and January 4 and attempted to treat the baby’s burns with soap, diaper rash cream, aloe, and baby ibuprofen. Although Bustamante did not take the baby to the hospital until January 4, 2023, Bustamante sent a Facebook message to a friend on January 1, 2023, about the possibility of taking the baby to the hospital because the baby’s skin was “peeling really bad.” In a Facebook voice memo to this friend, she described using a wet cloth to pick off all the loose skin because the baby “had skin everywhere.” She also texted another friend that the baby’s skin was peeling “really bad” and that she was taking him to the hospital because his skin looked terrible. When that friend later asked about the baby, Bustamante lied and told her that she was at the hospital with the baby.
Finally, on January 4, 2023, the day before the baby was scheduled for a doctor’s visit at the Young Eagle Clinic on Fort Campbell, Bustamante, accompanied by her five-year-old son and a friend, took the baby to Houston County Community Hospital. Garasich did not go with them to the hospital. Medical personnel at Houston County immediately determined that the baby needed to be life flighted to Vanderbilt University Medical Center due to the severity of his injuries and contacted the Erin Police Department, who dispatched officers to the hospital. When the baby was assessed at Vanderbilt, in addition to partial to full thickness burns on the baby’s buttocks, perineum, lower extremities, and left elbow, medical personnel also noted a left parietal skull fracture. The baby remained hospitalized at Vanderbilt University Medical Center for almost two months before being discharged. Both children are now in the custody of DCS.
Following her term of imprisonment, Bustamante will be on supervised release for 4 years.
Bustamante’s co-defendant, the child’s father Andrew J. Garasich, was sentenced on July 14, 2025, to 14 years in federal prison to be followed by 4 years of supervised release.
This case was investigated by the Department of the Army Criminal Investigation Division and the FBI Nashville Field Office, Clarksville Resident Agency. Assistant U.S. Attorney Monica Morrison and Acting United States Attorney Robert E. McGuire prosecuted the case.
# # # # #